the BLOG of stuart mcdonald

Does Race Really Matter?
March 2, 2010, 11:11 am
Filed under: race | Tags: , , , ,

Does race matter? It’s a question that was brought to me the other day. And in the midst of all that’s going on in America — the first black President in the White House, politicians remarking that black people were better off during slavery, celebrities using inappropriate and racially charged words — it’s a question that’s not out of place. So, does race matter?

I’m torn. Part of me wants to say that, no, race doesn’t matter. It shouldn’t matter. After all, race is a socially constructed concept with no real, inherently biological traits to distinguish any one person from any other person. Race is a category based on the society of which we’re a part at any given time. Race has changed over time, and indeed will continue to change as society itself changes. In other words, ultimately, it means nothing.

Even though race shouldn’t matter, it does. American society is so heavily impacted by race that you couldn’t ignore its effects if you tried. (You could ignorantly try to deny them, however.) Hundreds of years of white supremacy and racial bias have made race such an integral part of our national identity that we may never be able to get past the color of each others skin.

That may seem pessimistic, yes, but it’s also the reality of the racial situation in America. Post racial America doesn’t exists. When racism, discrimination, and segregation are built into the foundation — even the very legislation — of the country, how can you absolutely eliminate it but to demolish the country and start over?

While America’s federal government system may not (ever) be post racial, perhaps the more important question is: are you? Have we, individually, learned to, not ignore a person’s race, but treat everyone the same regardless of their race? Does race matter to you?

This may be the more pertinent question because race and ethnic identity are intensely person. They are who we are. racial and ethnic issues are often times best dealt with on a individual level. The best way to create a post-racial America is to make sure that your America — the circles and spheres of influence of which you’re a part — are post-racial.

We often hear people use the “but I have X number of (enter race here) friends,” line in order to defend themselves from accusations of prejudice, but without having friends and acquaintances that are racially and ethnically diverse, we will never learn, grow, and begin to understand those who are not like ourselves. We must make conscious choices to diversify (in every sense of the word) the people we interact with, if for no other reason than because being around a bunch of clones who act, think, and talk just like you gets to be more than a little boring. Not to mention the fact that you never learn anything new or how to articulate and defend you perspectives and opinions if you never experience a positive that’s opposite yours.

But who cares about understanding peoples who are different from us? Why is that important? How would that benefit our lives? If you’d like to remain ignorant, close-minded, and selfish, it doesn’t. But who wants to do that? America is growing increasingly diverse every day; it would behoove all of us to at least strive to understand cultures and people who are different than us. Can it hurt? I think not. Can it help? Absolutely.

[Make sure you follow me on Twitter and connect with me on Facebook.]


3 Comments so far
Leave a comment

I think that is a very hard and private question. I completely agree with you when you say ” The best way to create a post-racial America is to make sure that your America — the circles and spheres of influence of which you’re a part — are post-racial.” I try to do this. I know there have been times when I’ve thought, if not said, something that can probably be deemed as racist. But I don’t intentionally go out in the world hating all those that are not like me. Unfortunately, I think a lot of it has to do with how some of us are raised. We hear these prejudices from before we can walk or talk and that supposedly makes it ok. For anyone to change America, I think it has to start with oneself. Consciously change our thinking and then we can change the world.

Comment by Elle

@Elle, I think race is more public for some of us than it is for others. Just a note.

I would also like to challenge the idea that diversity necessarily yields understanding. In partnership with well structured dialogue, it can but not every friend that you have of another culture is going to be representative of that group’s experience.

It also reminds me of my experience at Morehouse College (an all-male, historically Black College) where I’ve come to understand more about the White experience than I have in my very isolating experiences as one of few Black people in a given situation. Being a member of the majority at Morehouse was probably a better teacher than what any single White friend could share.

Comment by Donovan

Race definitely MATTERS here in America. Here’s a recent example

Comment by Southern Laydee

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: